How Should Monetary Policy Respond to Asset-price Bubbles?
نویسندگان
چکیده
We present a simple model of the macroeconomy that includes a role for an assetprice bubble, and derive optimal monetary policy settings for two policy-makers. The first policy-maker, a sceptic, does not attempt to forecast the future possible paths for the asset-price bubble when setting policy. The second policy-maker, an activist, takes into account the complete stochastic implications of the bubble when setting policy. We examine the optimal policy recommendations of these two policy-makers across a range of plausible assumptions about the bubble. We show that the optimal monetary policy recommendations of the activist depend on the detailed stochastic properties of the bubble. There are some circumstances in which the activist clearly recommends tighter policy than that of the sceptic, while in other cases, the appropriate recommendation is to be looser than the sceptic. Other things equal, the case for ‘leaning against’ a bubble with monetary policy is stronger the lower the probability of the bubble bursting of its own accord, the larger the efficiency losses associated with big bubbles, and the higher the assumed impact of monetary policy on the bubble process. JEL Classification Numbers: E32, E52, E60
منابع مشابه
How Should Central Banks Respond to Asset-Price Bubbles? The ‘Lean’ versus ‘Clean’ Debate After the GFC
One of the most important issues facing central banks is whether they should respond to potential asset-price bubbles. Because asset prices are a central element in the transmission mechanisms of monetary policy, the issue of how monetary policy might respond to asset-price movements is not whether it should respond at all but whether it should respond over and above the response called for in ...
متن کاملShould Monetary Policy Respond to Asset Price Bubbles? Some Experimental Results
Should central banks respond to asset price bubbles? This paper explores this monetary policy question in a hypothetical economy subject to asset price bubbles. Despite the highly stylized structure of the model, the results reveal several practical monetary policy lessons. First, a monetary authority should generally respond to asset prices as long as asset prices contain reliable information ...
متن کاملDiscussion of How Should Monetary Policy Respond to Asset-price Bubbles?
The subject of the paper by David Gruen, Michael Plumb and Andrew Stone — how monetary policy should respond to asset prices — is obviously an important one. The formation of bubbles in asset prices and the eventual demise of those bubbles have the potential to cause damage to our economic and fi nancial systems. Macroeconomic instability in the form of unwelcome variability of output and infl ...
متن کاملHow Should Monetary Policy Respond to Asset-Price Bubbles? - IJCB - December 2005
We present a simple macroeconomic model that includes a role for an asset-price bubble. We then derive optimal monetary policy settings for two policymakers: a skeptic, for whom the best forecast of future asset prices is the current price; and an activist, whose policy recommendations take into account the complete stochastic implications of the bubble. We show that the activist’s recommendati...
متن کاملComments on “Optimal Monetary Policy in an Environment of Low Inflation
Periodically, some group of asset prices rises at a rapid pace that is matched neither by general price inflation nor seemingly by the relevant fundamental asset values. This situation rightfully causes great consternation at central banks, as it has dangerous implications for the stability of inflation and full employment and for financial stability. Some asset prices, such as those for housin...
متن کامل